A pond that is losing water isn’t always leaking. In summer, evaporation alone can take off around 1 to 2.5 cm (0.5 to 1 in) a week, and more on hot or windy days. Before you dig into the liner, rule out evaporation and splash from the waterfall. Then work through the tests below in order, because each one tells you where to look next.
Step 1: The bucket test
Fill a bucket with pond water and stand it on a shelf or step inside the pond, so the water in the bucket sits at about the same level as the pond. Mark the water level inside the bucket and the level outside it. Leave it for 24 to 48 hours, then compare.
If the pond has dropped more than the water in the bucket, you are losing water faster than evaporation explains, which points to a leak. If both have dropped by the same amount, the loss is most likely evaporation.
Step 2: The pump-off test
Switch off the pump, along with any waterfall, stream or fountain. Mark the water level and leave it for 24 to 48 hours. What happens next tells you where to look:
- The level stops dropping. The leak is most likely in the waterfall, the stream or the plumbing, not in the main basin.
- The level keeps dropping. The leak is most likely in the basin itself. The water usually stops falling at the height of the leak.
Step 3: Find the height where the water stops
If the level keeps dropping, let it fall until it stops. The line where it stops is roughly the height of the leak. Walk the edge of the pond at that line and check for soft or soggy soil, damp patches, mud oozing up, or air pockets behind the liner. A low or sagging liner edge is one of the most common places for water to escape.
Before you lower the water a long way, move the fish into an aerated holding tank. A pond with lots of fish can lose oxygen quickly when the volume drops.
Step 4: The dye test
With the pump off and the water still, squirt a little concentrated dye near the suspected spot. If there is a crack, a gap or a loose liner fold, the water will draw the dye into it. Some keepers use milk for a similar test if they don’t have dye.
If the dye test shows nothing and the level still drops, look at the fittings: the skimmer faceplate, pipe joins, and any bottom drain. Test them one at a time.
Common causes
Most leaks aren’t holes in the middle of the liner. They’re more often one of these:
- Low or sagging liner edges, where water spills over into the surrounding soil.
- Waterfall splash-out, where water lands outside the basin on the stream edge. Large rocks or heavy turbulence can make it worse.
- Soil or roots wicking water over the top of the liner, which carries it away from the basin.
- Shifted rocks pressing down on the liner and tearing it.
- Fittings and plumbing, such as a skimmer faceplate or a pipe joint.
Repairs by pond and liner type
EPDM liners
Clean and dry the area, then prime it with EPDM primer. Cut an EPDM patch that overlaps the damage by at least 5 cm (2 in) on every side, and press it down firmly. Patches won’t stick to a wet or dirty liner, so take the time to dry it properly.
PVC liners
Use a PVC patch and PVC adhesive. PVC patches won’t bond to EPDM, so check which liner you have before you buy a kit.
Low edges
If water spills over a low edge, raise the liner above the water line by packing soil or stones underneath it. This is often the cheapest fix for a leak that appears only at the edge.
Concrete ponds
Fill cracks with hydraulic cement, then coat the area with a pond-safe sealant. Check the sealant label to confirm that it’s safe for fish and plants.
Clay and earth ponds
Sodium bentonite, a clay that swells when wet, can reduce seepage in a clay or earth pond. How well it works depends on the soil, so treat it as a partial fix. Compacted clay layers are another option. Large or structural leaks in an earth pond are better handled with professional help.
Household fixes
Household tape and general-purpose silicone don’t make lasting repairs in a pond. Use a product made for ponds.
How long do pond liners last?
A 45 mil (about 1.1 mm) EPDM liner is a common choice. EPDM and butyl liners often last 20 years or more. PVC liners typically last about 10 to 15 years. Sunlight (UV) is a major factor, so shade and a good underlay help. Geotextile underlay also protects the liner from roots and stones.
How to naturally seal a clay or earth pond
For a clay or earth pond, sodium bentonite is one of the more natural options. Results vary with the soil, and it isn’t a guaranteed fix. It isn’t a substitute for repairing a torn liner in a lined pond. Ask a local pond or farm pond specialist if you’re unsure whether it will work for your soil.
What repairs cost
A patch kit is usually one of the cheapest fixes. Larger jobs, such as relining the pond or repairing a structural problem, cost much more, and prices vary by region and pond size. Get a quote for anything that goes beyond a patch.
Safety
Unplug the pump before working in the pond. Move fish to an aerated holding tank before lowering the water a lot. Take care on wet, slippery edges, and don’t work alone if the pond is deep. Wear gloves when handling pond water or sludge, and cover any cuts.