Pond Building

Pond Liners and Sealants: Choosing Materials and Waterproofing

Compare EPDM, butyl, PVC and RPE pond liners, check fish-safe coatings for concrete and block, and plan any bottom drain before you start building.

On this page
  1. Choose the liner before you dig
  2. Flexible liners compared
  3. Only use liners labelled fish-safe
  4. Concrete, block and fibreglass walls
  5. Coatings for concrete and block
  6. What not to paint with
  7. Bentonite and clay sealing for earth ponds
  8. Bottom drains through the liner
  9. Repairing a leaking liner
  10. Choosing the right material

Choose the liner before you dig

The liner or wall finish decides whether the pond holds water and whether it is safe for fish. It also sets the shape you can build and how much maintenance you will do over the years. Decide on it before you dig, because a bottom drain or a particular shape can change the excavation.

Most backyard ponds use one of three approaches: a flexible liner over an excavated hole, a preformed rigid shell, or walls of concrete, block or stone that are then sealed. The preformed kit guide covers shells, and the raised pond guide covers block walls.

Flexible liners compared

Flexible liners are the most common choice for a dug pond because they follow any shape. The main types differ in thickness, flexibility and how well they handle sunlight.

  • EPDM rubber. Typically 45 mil (about 1.1 mm). It stays flexible in cold weather, and lifespans of 20 years or more are often quoted, though manufacturer claims vary. It is the usual recommendation for DIY ponds. Seams are joined with seam tape and primer.
  • Butyl rubber. About 0.75 mm thick and common in the UK. Like EPDM, it is often quoted at 20 years or more. Small punctures are repaired with butyl tape or patches.
  • PVC. Typically 20 to 32 mil. It is cheaper than EPDM but less resistant to UV light, and it is often quoted at around 5 to 15 years. Making PVC thicker does not match EPDM’s UV and cold resistance.
  • RPE (reinforced polyethylene). Typically 20 to 30 mil. It is lighter than EPDM for its thickness and more resistant to punctures by weight.
  • HDPE. Stiff and usually seam-welded. It is used more on large or commercial ponds than on garden ponds.

Whichever liner you choose, the underlay matters as much as the liner itself. The underlayment guide explains which fabrics suit each site.

Only use liners labelled fish-safe

Buy a liner sold as fish-safe, or as safe for potable water, for any pond that will hold fish or plants you eat. Roofing EPDM is cheaper, but it may contain algaecides or fire retardants that are not meant for water with animals in it. Check the product label or the supplier before you buy.

Concrete, block and fibreglass walls

Concrete and block can make a strong, long-lasting pond, but neither material is waterproof on its own. Concrete cracks, and mortar or render alone does not stop water from passing through block.

New concrete also needs care. Uncoated new concrete leaches lime, which can push the water’s pH above 9. Let new concrete cure for about 28 days, then seal it or neutralise it before fish go in.

A fibreglass (GRP) resin lining over concrete or block is a common finish for koi ponds, especially in the UK. It gives a smooth, durable surface, but the work is specialised, so get it done properly or hire someone with experience.

Coatings for concrete and block

Pond coatings fall into three main types:

  • Two-part epoxy, which is hard and durable but needs ventilation and gloves during application.
  • Polyurethane, which may be moisture-curing. Some products are sold as fish-safe.
  • Liquid or rubberised coatings, which can bridge hairline cracks.

Cementitious coatings are also sold for ponds. One manufacturer’s sheet calls for a 7 to 10 day drying period before filling and no application below 40°F (4°C) or above 100°F (38°C). Check the instructions for the product you choose.

When you check a coating, look for these points:

  • Labelled as pond- or fish-safe. NSF/ANSI 61 (potable water) certification is a good sign of a non-toxic cure, but not every pond product carries it.
  • Surface preparation. The surface must be clean, dry and sound. Remove loose laitance and etch or abrade the surface as the product instructions say.
  • Weather limits. Moisture and temperature limits during application vary by product. Check the label.
  • Full cure. Coatings must cure fully before filling. This usually takes several days to about a week, depending on product and temperature.
  • Rinse and drain. Follow the manufacturer’s advice, which often includes a rinse and drain after the cure.

A dark coating makes the pond look deeper and hides algae, so colour is worth thinking about too. Structural cracks need repair before coating, because a coating only seals hairline cracks.

What not to paint with

Ordinary exterior, masonry and house paint is not safe for fish, so do not use it as a pond coating. Swimming pool paint is not the same as pond paint, and some pool paints contain biocides. Driveway and concrete sealers are not designed for constant immersion.

Pond coatings also need time to cure, unlike house paint, which dries within hours. Keep fish out until the coating has cured and been rinsed. Painting over a leaking liner will not fix the leak. Patch the liner with its repair kit instead. The paint guide goes into more detail on what to use.

Bentonite and clay sealing for earth ponds

Sodium bentonite is a clay that swells when wet and can seal leaky soil in an earth pond. Application rates are commonly quoted at about 1 to 3 lb per square foot, but the right rate depends on the soil. Sandy soil needs far more. Bentonite does not fix every leak, and it is not a repair for a damaged liner. Clay soil is also not automatically watertight, so see the clay soil article before you rely on it.

Bottom drains through the liner

A bottom drain lets you remove debris from the floor of the pond. The drain pipe passes through the liner, sealed with a clamp-ring flange and gaskets on either side of the liner.

Some key points:

  • The pipe is commonly 3 to 4 in (75 to 110 mm) and gravity-fed to a filter or settlement chamber.
  • The pond floor should slope gently toward the drain.
  • Garden ponds usually lack bottom drains, while koi ponds often have them.
  • Bottom drains are hard to add to a finished, lined pond, so plan the drain before you build.

For the difference between pond drains and pool drains, and why gravity-fed pond drains do not create the same suction risk, see the pool drain article.

Repairing a leaking liner

Liner leaks often start at an edge, a seam or a waterfall join, rather than a hole in the middle of the floor. Check those areas first.

  • EPDM seams are joined with seam tape and primer, and small punctures can be patched with the liner manufacturer’s kit.
  • Butyl small punctures are repaired with butyl tape or patches.
  • Coated concrete with hairline cracks can be resealed with a liquid coating. Structural cracks need repair before recoating.

Painting over the leak is not a fix. Find the source first.

Choosing the right material

Work through these questions before you buy:

  • Is the pond flexible-lined or built with hard walls?
  • Will fish or edible plants live in it? If so, is the material labelled fish-safe?
  • Does the climate get cold? EPDM stays flexible in cold weather.
  • Do you want a bottom drain? Plan it before you dig.
  • Have you sized the liner from the maximum depth? The garden pond guide explains how.

The complete guide to pond building

How to Build a Garden Pond: Planning, Digging and Design
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →